At Thanksgiving, everyone is an intellectual property lawyer for about fifteen minutes. Aunt Linda claims exclusive rights to the stuffing. Uncle Frank insists he invented deep-fried turkey. Your cousin says he can use anyone’s pie photo on Instagram as long as he gives credit. The only person exercising sound judgment is the one who brought rolls.
Can Aunt Linda copyright her stuffing?
The ingredient list and basic cooking directions generally fall outside copyright protection. Linda’s original photos and the essay she wrote about why her sister was wrong to add raisins could qualify for protection. You can make the stuffing. Copying her photos and essay for your own cookbook raises a different question.
As for the raisins, the Copyright Office has wisely declined to take a position.
What if she starts selling it?
Suppose Linda starts selling boxed stuffing under the name CRUMB WITNESS. If customers recognize the name as identifying her product, it can function as a trademark. If a competitor puts KRUMB WITNESS on its own boxed stuffing, changing the first letter does little to change what shoppers hear when they ask for it. The trademark question is whether shoppers are likely to think the products come from the same source.
If the packaging just says STUFFING, shoppers have learned what’s for dinner. They still have no idea who made it.
Is the gravy recipe a trade secret?
A commercially valuable recipe can qualify as a trade secret when its value comes from being secret and its owner takes reasonable steps to keep it that way. If Uncle Frank runs a gravy business and limits access to the formula, there may be something to protect. If he posted the recipe in the family group chat last year and his sister put it on Facebook, the evidence may be available under “Memories.”
By dessert, Linda has a potential trademark, Frank has a confidentiality problem, and your cousin is about to find out that photo credit and permission are two different things. The rolls, meanwhile, are gone. Nobody even asked who made them.
Happy Thanksgiving from Lee Law PLLC.
This article provides general information about U.S. intellectual property law and does not constitute legal advice.